Errata in ISO 8041
These are the 4 entries of the errata registry on ISO 8041-1:2017 and ISO 8041-2:2021, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 8041-1:2017, clause 12.7 (“the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1)” for Wf)
Section titled “ISO 8041-1:2017, clause 12.7 (“the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1)” for Wf)”- Location: clause 12.7, printed folio 30 (PDF page 30 of the ISO release, PDF page 38 of the copy read here), fourth paragraph. The clause opens on printed folio 29.
- The print: “For each frequency weighting provided, a steady sinusoidal electrical signal shall be applied to the electrical input facility at the appropriate reference frequency. With an input signal adjusted to indicate the reference vibration value on the reference measurement range with band-limiting frequency weighting, the indicated frequency-weighted vibration values shall equal the indicated band-limited weighted vibration value multiplied by the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1) within the tolerance limits of Table 2.”
- The problem: the pointer to Table 1 names a quantity the test cannot be
satisfied with. The test fixes the input so that the band-limited
indication reads the reference value, so the frequency-weighted indication a
conforming meter shows is
: the
factor that closes the identity is the
ratio of the two responses at the reference frequency, not the overall
weighting Table 1 prints. For eight of the nine weightings the distinction is
invisible, because their band-limiting weighting sits between 0.999 68 and
0.999 97 at their own reference frequency and the two readings agree to
0.03 %.
Wfis the exception: its reference frequency of 2.5 rad/s = 0.397 887 Hz falls inside its own band-limiting skirt, whose corners Table 3 puts at 0.08 Hz and 0.63 Hz. There the band-limiting weighting is 0.928 078 and the overall weighting 0.388 848, which Table B.5 prints as 0.927 9 and 0.388 4 at the neighbouring 0.398 1 Hz band centre. Read as the 0.388 8 of Table 1, the row demands a value that a conformingWfmeter’s indication exceeds by 7.76 % of that demanded value (), against the ±5 % Table 2 allows low-frequency whole-body vibration: half again over the limit, on an instrument with no defect. Read as the ratio 0.418 982, the row is true by construction. - Evidence: the printed clause against Table 1 (printed folio 9), Table 2 (printed folio 12), Table 3 (printed folios 12 to 13) and Table B.5. The two responses at 2.5 rad/s are evaluated from the Formula (1) to (5) cascade the same Table 3 parameters define, and they reproduce the two Table B.5 columns at the neighbouring band centre to four figures. Verified on PDF page 38 (printed p. 30) of ISO 8041-1:2017(E).
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none. Annex B tabulates the band-limiting weighting and the overall weighting in separate columns, so both readings can be recovered from it; only clause 12.7’s one-line instruction is ambiguous.
- Library behaviour:
band_limited_weighting_factorreturns the ratio, which is the reading that makes the test satisfiable, and its docstring tabulates the two readings side by side for all nine weightings so a report can say which one it used.reference_indicationreturns the Table 1 product, which is the other quantity and the one the reference-conditions row of Table 1 is about. - Status: unreported.
ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.7 (“the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1)” for Wf, carried over from Part 1)
Section titled “ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.7 (“the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1)” for Wf, carried over from Part 1)”- Location: clause 12.7, printed folio 26 (PDF page 34), the second paragraph on that folio. The clause opens on printed folio 25.
- The print: the sentence of ISO 8041-1:2017 12.7 recorded in the entry
above, word for word: “With an input signal adjusted to indicate the
reference vibration value on the reference measurement range with
band-limiting frequency weighting, the indicated frequency-weighted
vibration values shall equal the indicated band-limited weighted vibration
value multiplied by the appropriate weighting factor (see Table 1) within
the tolerance limits of Table 2.” Table 1 of this document prints the same
weighting factor for
Wfat 2,5 rad/s, 0,388 8, and Table 3 the sameWfparameters, with its band-limiting corners at 0,08 Hz and 0,63 Hz. - The problem: the ISO 8041-1:2017 defect, carried into the personal
vibration exposure meter. Part 2 keeps
Wfamong the weightings a PVEM may provide, with the same reference frequency inside the same band-limiting skirt, so the arithmetic of the entry above holds unchanged: read as the 0.388 8 of Table 1, the paragraph demands a value that a conformingWfmeter’s indication exceeds by 7.76 % of that demanded value (), outside the ±3 % that the second row of Table 2 allows the difference and outside the ±5 % its first row allows a low-frequency whole-body indication. Read as the ratio of the overall weighting to the band-limiting one at the reference frequency, 0.418 982, the paragraph is true by construction. - Evidence: the printed clause against Table 1 (printed folio 5) and
Tables 2 and 3 (printed folio 8), whose
Wfrow carries the parameters ISO 8041-1:2017 prints. Verified on PDF pages 13, 16 and 34 (printed pp. 5, 8 and 26) of ISO 8041-2:2021(E). - Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none, as in Part 1.
- Library behaviour: unchanged by this entry.
band_limited_weighting_factorreturns the ratio, and it serves both parts because Part 2 prints the same weightings. The conformance row “ISO 8041-2:2021 Table 2” records the tolerances this paragraph is judged against. - Status: unreported.
ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.7 (time weightings graded against a row Table 2 no longer prints)
Section titled “ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.7 (time weightings graded against a row Table 2 no longer prints)”- Location: clause 12.7, printed folio 26 (PDF page 34), the third paragraph on that folio; read against Table 2 on printed folio 8, clause 5.13 on printed folio 15, clause 5.1.2 on printed folio 6 and Table 8 on printed folios 13 and 14.
- The print: “For an instrument where time weightings are provided, a steady sinusoidal electrical signal shall be applied to the electrical input facility at the reference frequency. […] With the same input signal, the indicated vibration values on each time weighting shall equal the indicated reference vibration value within the tolerance limits of Table 2.” Table 2 prints two rows: the tolerance of indication at the reference frequency (±4 %, and ±5 % for low-frequency whole-body vibration) and the difference between a frequency-weighted indication and the band-limited one times the weighting factor (±3 %). Clause 5.13, “Running RMS acceleration”, reads in full: “Not applicable for PVEM.”
- The problem: the paragraph is the one ISO 8041-1:2017 prints in its own 12.7 (printed folio 30 of that document), with “the vibration meter” turned into “the PVEM”, and there the limit it points at is the third row of the Part 1 Table 2: the running r.m.s. indication against the linear time-averaged one, ±2 %. The time weighting in this family of standards is that running r.m.s.; Part 1 titles its Tables 10 and 11 “Time-weighting decay rates”. Part 2 dropped the row, since its 5.13 declares the running r.m.s. not applicable, and kept the paragraph that grades it, so the paragraph now sends the reader to a table in which no row states a limit for a time-weighted indication. And the document itself lets a PVEM carry one: its 5.1.2 (printed folio 6) allows a whole-body PVEM to “optionally, measure exposure characteristics based on maximum transient vibration value (MTVV)”, which ISO 8041-1:2017 3.1.2.4, adopted by clause 3, defines as the “maximum value of the running r.m.s. vibration acceleration value when the integration time is equal to 1 s”, and its Table 8 (printed folios 13 and 14) grades the “MTVV linear” and “MTVV exponential” of that running r.m.s. in the burst. For a PVEM that provides no time weighting the paragraph is empty; for one that reports the MTVV, the document does not say what limit the indication on each time weighting is held to.
- Evidence: the three printed passages against each other, against 5.1.2 and Table 8, and against ISO 8041-1:2017 12.7 and its Table 2, which print the running r.m.s. row this paragraph was written for. Verified on PDF pages 14, 16, 21, 22, 23 and 34 (printed pp. 6, 8, 13, 14, 15 and 26) of ISO 8041-2:2021(E), and on PDF pages 13, 20, 28 and 38 (printed pp. 5, 12, 20 and 30) of ISO 8041-1:2017(E) for the definition of the MTVV, the Part 1 Table 2, the title of its Table 10 and its 12.7.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none. The defect is a cross-reference that outlived its row.
- Library behaviour:
PVEM_INDICATION_TOLERANCES_PERCENTpublishes the two rows Part 2 prints and no running r.m.s. row, so nothing in the library grades a PVEM on this paragraph; the Part 1 row remainsRUNNING_RMS_CONSISTENCY_TOLERANCE_PERCENT, documented as Part 1 only. The conformance row “ISO 8041-2:2021 Table 2” records the two rows. - Status: unreported.
ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.22 (“exited” for “excited”)
Section titled “ISO 8041-2:2021, clause 12.22 (“exited” for “excited”)”- Location: clause 12.22, “Logging capabilities”, printed folio 36 (PDF page 44), the first paragraph of the clause.
- The print: “Part A of the PVEM shall be placed on a shaker and be exited 2 times for at least 300 s each.”
- The problem: “exited” where the sense is “excited”: the part is put on a shaker to be vibrated twice, once at each end of the 12 h run, and the paragraph that follows on printed folio 37 counts the 600 logged samples that “correspond to the vibration magnitude”, which is those two 300 s excitations at one sample per second. As printed, the verb says the part leaves the shaker twice.
- Evidence: PDF page 44 (printed p. 36) of ISO 8041-2:2021(E), and PDF page 45 (printed p. 37) for the 600 samples.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none.
- Library behaviour: unaffected. The 12 h logging test of 12.22 is a test on a physical meter and is not implemented.
- Status: unreported (typographic, no numerical consequence).
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects