Errata in ISO 11546
These are the 6 entries of the errata registry on ISO 11546-1:1995 and ISO 11546-2:1995, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 11546-1:1995, 9.4 c) (a quantity cross-referenced to the uncertainty clause)
Section titled “ISO 11546-1:1995, 9.4 c) (a quantity cross-referenced to the uncertainty clause)”- Location: item 9.4 c) 2) on printed page 9 (PDF page 16 of the BS EN ISO 11546-1:2009 copy read here, whose folios run seven behind the PDF pages), against clause 8 on printed page 8.
- The print: “2) A-weighted sound power insulation, (see clause 8);”, listed under “9.4 Acoustical data” among the quantities a measurement with the actual sound source has to record.
- The problem: clause 8 of this part is “Uncertainty”, and it says nothing about : it states the standard deviations expected of each method and sends a declared value to ISO 4871. is defined in definition 3.9 and computed by Equation (2) of 6.2. A reader following the cross-reference arrives at a clause that does not define the quantity it was sent to find.
- Evidence: item 9.4 c) 2) on printed page 9 and the heading and body of clause 8 on printed page 8. Verified on PDF page 16 (printed p. 9) and PDF page 15 (printed p. 8) of ISO 11546-1:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-1:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none; Equation (2) is printed correctly where it belongs.
- Library behaviour:
enclosure_sound_power_insulationreturns from Equation (2) and cites 6.2 for it. - Status: not reported.
ISO 11546-1:1995, clause 8 (a misspelt word in the uncertainty statement)
Section titled “ISO 11546-1:1995, clause 8 (a misspelt word in the uncertainty statement)”- Location: the first paragraph of clause 8 on printed page 8 (PDF page 15).
- The print: “When the actual sound source or the artificial sound source method is used, it is expected that measurements in confirmity with this part of ISO 11546 will yield standard deviations which are equal to or less than those given in the International Standard used.”
- The problem: “confirmity” for “conformity”. The sentence is the one that attaches the whole uncertainty statement of the part to a condition, so the misspelt word is the one that says when the statement holds.
- Evidence: the first paragraph of clause 8 on printed page 8. Verified on PDF page 15 (printed p. 8) of ISO 11546-1:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-1:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none.
- Library behaviour: none to take; no number depends on it.
- Status: not reported.
ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, Table C.1 (a column headed with a standard that does not exist)
Section titled “ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, Table C.1 (a column headed with a standard that does not exist)”- Location: Table C.1 on printed page 12 (PDF page 18 of the BS EN ISO 11546-2:2009 copy read here, whose folios run six behind the PDF pages).
- The print: the last column of the table is headed “ISO 10204”, carrying footnote markers 3) and 4), over the cells and . Footnote 4) under the same table reads “If , the method specified in ISO 11204 is classified as an engineering method.”
- The problem: ISO 10204 is a metallic-products inspection-document standard and has nothing to do with acoustics. The column is ISO 11204, as its own footnote says and as the paragraph above the table says: the annex opens by naming “ISO 3743-1, ISO 3744, ISO 3746, ISO 3747, ISO 9614-1, ISO 9614-2, ISO 11201, ISO 11202 and ISO 11204”, with no ISO 10204 among them, and repeats the list before step a).
- Evidence: the column head and its footnote 4) in Table C.1 on printed page 12, against the two lists on the same page. Verified on PDF page 18 (printed p. 12) of ISO 11546-2:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-2:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none; the two cells under the head are the ISO 11204 requirements and are correct.
- Library behaviour:
TEST_ENVIRONMENT_REQUIREMENTSkeys that column as"ISO 11204", and a test asserts that no"ISO 10204"key exists. - Status: not reported.
ISO 11546-2:1995, definition 3.11 (an estimate that points at the wrong annex)
Section titled “ISO 11546-2:1995, definition 3.11 (an estimate that points at the wrong annex)”- Location: definition 3.11 on printed page 3 (PDF page 9), against Annex C and Annex D on printed pages 12 and 15.
- The print: “3.11 estimated noise insulation due to the enclosure, or : Calculated reduction in A-weighted sound power or sound pressure level obtained from or , measured in accordance with this part of ISO 11546, and a specific noise spectrum. (See annex C.)”
- The problem: Annex C of this part is “Guidelines for evaluating the applicability of different test environments for in situ measurements”, which computes no such estimate. The quantity the definition names is computed in Annex D, “Estimated noise insulation due to the enclosure for a specific noise spectrum”. The cross-reference is the one part 1 carries, where the estimate genuinely is Annex C; part 2 inserted the test environment annex before it and the pointer was not moved.
- Evidence: the definition on printed page 3 and the titles of Annex C and Annex D on printed pages 12 and 15. Verified on PDF page 9 (printed p. 3), PDF page 18 (printed p. 12) and PDF page 21 (printed p. 15) of ISO 11546-2:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-2:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none; the formula is the same in both parts.
- Library behaviour:
estimated_a_weighted_enclosure_insulationcites Annex C of part 1 and Annex D of part 2, which is where each prints it. - Status: not reported.
ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, steps c) and d) (a subscript on the wrong half of a ratio)
Section titled “ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, steps c) and d) (a subscript on the wrong half of a ratio)”- Location: the lettered procedure of Annex C on printed page 12 (PDF page 18).
- The print: “c) Calculate for the actual situation ()” and “d) If determined from figure C.1, the test environment is estimated to be applicable.”
- The problem: the word “actual” qualifies the situation, not the measurement surface, but it is printed as a subscript on alone, so the expression reads as over an “actual ” and step d) reads as a comparison of two different ratios of the same . There is one measurement surface in the procedure; the two sides of the inequality are the ratio of the room being judged and the ratio read off Figure C.1 at the same .
- Evidence: steps c) and d) and the paragraph above them on printed page 12. Verified on PDF page 18 (printed p. 12) of ISO 11546-2:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-2:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none; Figure C.1 is a curve and the annex prints no worked case.
- Library behaviour:
check_enclosure_test_environmentreturnsactual_area_ratioandrequired_area_ratioas two named ratios of the same measurement surface, so the comparison cannot be read the other way. - Status: not reported.
ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, first paragraph (a normative reference list with a misspelt word)
Section titled “ISO 11546-2:1995, Annex C, first paragraph (a normative reference list with a misspelt word)”- Location: the opening paragraph of Annex C on printed page 12 (PDF page 18).
- The print: “In these standards, detailed requirements concerning testing conditions and evironments are stated.”
- The problem: “evironments” for “environments”. The sentence is the one that establishes what the whole annex is for, and the annex title, the paragraph after it and Table C.1 all spell the word correctly.
- Evidence: the opening paragraph on printed page 12, against the annex title on the same page. Verified on PDF page 18 (printed p. 12) of ISO 11546-2:1995 as published in BS EN ISO 11546-2:2009.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none.
- Library behaviour: none to take; no number depends on it.
- Status: not reported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects