Errata in ISO 4869
These are the 3 entries of the errata registry on ISO 4869-2:2018, ISO 4869-6:2019 and ISO 4869-3:2007, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 4869-2:2018, Table C.1 (the reprint that disagrees with the table it reprints)
Section titled “ISO 4869-2:2018, Table C.1 (the reprint that disagrees with the table it reprints)”- Location: Annex C (informative), Table C.1, “A-weighted octave-band sound pressure levels, , from Table 2”, PDF page 17 (printed p. 11), against the normative Table 2 it names, PDF page 11 (printed p. 5).
- The print: the two tables carry the same eight reference noises over the same seven octave bands, and seven of the eight rows agree digit for digit. The sixth reads 82,0 / 89,3 / 93,3 / 95,6 / 93,0 / 90,1 / 83,0 in Table 2 and 82,0 / 89,4 / 93,5 / 95,6 / 93,0 / 90,1 / 83,0 in Table C.1. The 250 Hz and 500 Hz cells differ; nothing else does.
- The problem: Table C.1 states in its own caption that it comes from Table 2, so one of the two is wrong, and the annex’s own results say which. Formula (15) applied to the sixteen attenuation values of Table A.1 with Table 2’s row reproduces all sixteen of Table C.2 exactly; with Table C.1’s row, thirteen of the sixteen fall 0.1 dB short. Table 2 is therefore the reading the worked example was computed from, and it is also the normative one, Table C.1 being an informative reprint. An implementer who takes the reference spectra from Annex C, where they sit next to the worked example, gets a protector’s and values a tenth of a decibel low.
- Evidence: Formula (15), PDF page 11 (printed p. 5), evaluated on Table A.1, PDF page 15 (printed p. 9), against the sixth row of Table C.2, PDF page 18 (printed p. 12), all of ISO 4869-2:2018.
- Library behaviour:
HML_REFERENCE_NOISEScarries Table 2. The test suite computes the same row from Table C.1’s values and asserts that it misses thirteen of the printed sixteen, so the two readings can never be silently swapped. - Status: unreported.
ISO 4869-6:2019, Table A.3 (the uncertainty rows are formed from the rounded row above them)
Section titled “ISO 4869-6:2019, Table A.3 (the uncertainty rows are formed from the rounded row above them)”- Location: Annex A (normative), Table A.3 “An example of ANR earmuff active insertion loss test data in dB for a given laboratory”, the rows “Combined standard uncertainty, , ()” and “Expanded uncertainty, ”, PDF page 16 (printed p. 10), against the definitions of A.1 and A.2 on PDF page 14 (printed p. 8).
- The print: the table gives the active insertion loss of sixteen subjects at the octave frequencies 63 Hz to 8 kHz, then their mean, their standard deviation , and . The row reads 0,5 / 0,2 / 0,4 / 0,5 / 0,4 / 0,4 / 0,4 / 0,2 dB and the row 1,0 / 0,4 / 0,8 / 1,0 / 0,8 / 0,8 / 0,8 / 0,4 dB. A.2 defines as “the standard deviation of the individual active insertion loss data divided by the square root of the number of test subjects, i.e. ”, and A.1 defines as multiplied by the coverage factor . The table carries no note on how it rounds.
- The problem: from the sixteen printed rows, the mean and reproduce in all sixteen cells, but at 250 Hz is 0.348 dB, which rounds to 0.3 and not 0.4, and is 0.935 / 0.355 / 0.697 / 0.940 / 0.711 / 0.839 / 0.720 / 0.325 dB, which rounds to 0.9 / 0.4 / 0.7 / 0.9 / 0.7 / 0.8 / 0.7 / 0.3: six of the eight printed cells are 0.1 dB high. Every printed cell is instead the formula applied to the rounded row above it: prints as 0.4, and each is twice the printed over it. The same table in ISO 4869-1:2018 (its Table A.3, same layout) computes at full precision and says so in its NOTE 2, “All calculations are made with full precision before rounding to one decimal”, and all 28 of its derived cells reproduce that way. A reader who applies A.1 and A.2 to the printed data of ISO 4869-6 gets an expanded uncertainty a tenth of a decibel below the printed one in six bands of eight, and cannot tell from the page why.
- Evidence: the sixteen rows and four derived rows of Table A.3, PDF page 16 (printed p. 10), recomputed with and once at full precision and once from the printed and ; A.1 and A.2, PDF page 14 (printed p. 8); all of ISO 4869-6:2019. For the contrast, ISO 4869-1:2018 Table A.3 and its NOTE 2, PDF page 19 (printed p. 13).
- Library behaviour:
hearing.active_insertion_lossreturns and at full precision from the data, as A.1 and A.2 define them. The conformance row andtests/hearing/test_active_noise_reduction.pypin the mean and rows as printed, reproduce the and rows the way the table forms them, and assert that full precision differs in exactly the seven cells named here, each by 0.1 dB. - Status: unreported.
ISO 4869-3:2007, 5.2.2 and Table 1 (a microphone index of exactly 5 dB in two rows)
Section titled “ISO 4869-3:2007, 5.2.2 and Table 1 (a microphone index of exactly 5 dB in two rows)”- Location: 5.2.2, the paragraph on the directional test, and Table 1, printed p. 4.
- The print: 5.2.2: “the range of sound pressure levels at the reference point shall be within 5 dB for any two directions of measurement of the incident sound energy when measured with a directional microphone with a front-to-random sensitivity index of at least 5 dB. For other directional microphones, the relationship between the front-to-random sensitivity index and the allowable field variations is given in Table 1.” Table 1 prints the rows ”> 5” (5 dB), “4 to 5” (4 dB) and ”< 4” (microphone not suitable).
- The problem: a microphone whose index is exactly 5 dB may read 5 dB by the text, which asks for “at least 5 dB”, and 4 dB by the table, whose first row excludes 5 and whose second includes it. The allowable variation of the one microphone the text names is therefore not decided by the page. ISO 8253-2:2009, which prints the same directional test in 5.3 b), writes the first row of its own Table 1 as ”≥ 5”.
- Evidence: the table read against the sentence that introduces it. Verified on PDF page 8 (printed p. 4) of ISO 4869-3:2007, and on PDF page 13 (printed p. 7) of ISO 8253-2:2009.
- Library behaviour: follows the text.
RANDOM_INCIDENCE_VARIATION_LIMITSallows 5 dB from an index of 5 dB and 4 dB from 4 dB up to below 5 dB, and the conformance check “ISO 4869-3:2007 5.2.2, Table 1” pins the row for 5 dB. A field that meets 4 dB passes either reading. - Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects