Errata in ISO 3891
This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO 3891:1978. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 3891:1978, Annex A, Table 9 (seven cells a unit above Table 10 where the humidity drops out)
Section titled “ISO 3891:1978, Annex A, Table 9 (seven cells a unit above Table 10 where the humidity drops out)”- Location: Annex A, Table 9 “Sound attenuation coefficient in dB/100 m for 1/3 octave band analysis”, relative humidity 70 %, set against Table 10, relative humidity 80 %, printed below it on the same page.
- The print: Table 9 prints 0,2 at 200 Hz and at 250 Hz for 20 °C, 0,4 at 500 Hz for 35 °C and at 800 Hz for 10 °C, 0,7 at 1 000 Hz for 30 °C, 1,0 at 1 600 Hz for 25 °C and 2,9 at 5 000 Hz for 25 °C. Table 10 prints 0,1, 0,1, 0,3, 0,3, 0,6, 0,9 and 2,8 in the same seven cells.
- The problem: in these seven cells the humidity does not enter the coefficient. The factor of A.2 is 0.200 from onwards (Table 1), and in each of these cells is past 6.50 at 70 % as well as at 80 %, so the formula gives the one value 0.104, 0.130, 0.349, 0.349, 0.642, 0.946 and 2.849 dB/100 m for both tables. Table 10 prints each of them rounded; Table 9 prints each one unit of the last digit above it, which at 200 Hz and 250 Hz and 20 °C doubles the coefficient, and reads against its own neighbours at 15 °C and 25 °C, both printed 0.1. The same formula, with read by the three-point quadratic Table 1 asks for, reproduces all 264 cells of Table 10 from 50 Hz to 10 kHz to the printed digit. Against Table 9 it misses eight more cells, by one unit, where does depend on the humidity: 800 Hz at 5 °C, 1 250 Hz at 0 °C and at 5 °C, 2 000 Hz at 10 °C, 4 000 Hz at 0 °C, 6 300 Hz at 10 °C and at 20 °C, and 8 000 Hz at 5 °C. Each of them lies within 0.014 dB/100 m of a rounding boundary, no reading of Table 1 tried (the three-point quadratic, linear, monotone cubic, Akima, cubic spline) reproduces them all, and no second table contradicts them, so they are not registered here. Five of the seven cells above lie as close to a boundary, within 0.009 dB/100 m; the 200 Hz and 250 Hz cells, at 0.104 and 0.130, do not.
- Evidence: the two tables compared cell by cell where A.2 makes them equal, and recomputation of both. Verified on PDF page 19 (printed p. 16) of ISO 3891:1978, which carries Tables 9 and 10, and on PDF pages 14 and 15 (printed pp. 11 and 12) of the same document for the formula of A.2 and Table 1.
- Library behaviour:
attenuation_arp866aevaluates the formula and reproduces Table 10; the conformance row ISO 3891:1978 Annex A Table 10 holds that table,test_iso3891_table_9_contradicts_table_10_where_humidity_drops_outpins the seven cells, andtest_iso3891_table_9_misses_are_the_seven_errata_and_eight_near_boundariescounts all fifteen. - Status: unreported. ISO 3891:1978 is withdrawn.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects