Skip to content

Errata in ISO/TS 12913

These are the 7 entries of the errata registry on ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 and ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Annex A.3 (the perceived affective quality called part 3)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Annex A.3 (the perceived affective quality called part 3)”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), A.3, the paragraph that introduces Formulas (A.1) and (A.2).
  • The print: “The results from part 3 (see A.1) are further processed to derive the values on two dimensions (pleasantness and eventfulness) for each site.”
  • The problem: the eight attributes the two formulas read (annoying, calm, chaotic, eventful, monotonous, pleasant, uneventful, vibrant) are the perceived affective quality, which is part 2 of the Method A questionnaire everywhere else the documents name it: in Table A.1 on the page before (“2 (perceived affective quality)”), in the A.2 paragraph that assigns its scale values 5 to 1 (“questionnaire part 2 (see Figure C.4 …)”), in the title of A.3 itself (“based on perceived affective quality responses”), and in ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, C.3.1.3 and Figure C.4, “Questionnaire part 2: Perceived affective quality”. Part 3 is the single overall rating of Figure C.5, “Overall, how would you describe the present surrounding sound environment?”, which has no attributes and cannot feed either formula. The cross-reference “(see A.1)” does not help: A.1 is the general clause and names no part. The sentence should read “part 2 (see A.2 and Table A.1)”.
  • Evidence: the sentence on PDF page 11 (printed p. 5), Table A.1 and the A.2 paragraphs on PDF page 10 (printed p. 4), both of ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 (first edition, 2019-12); C.3.1.3 on PDF page 21 (printed p. 15) and Figures C.4 and C.5 on PDF page 22 (printed p. 16) of ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 (first edition).
  • Library behaviour: pleasantness_eventfulness applies Formulas (A.1) and (A.2) to the eight attributes of part 2, the only reading under which they can be evaluated (soundscape.py). No change was required. The 2025 edition of ISO/TS 12913-3 revises Annex A and has not been checked for this entry.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (A.3) (a stray factor 1)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (A.3) (a stray factor 1)”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), A.4, Formula (A.3), Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient for untied ranks.
  • The print: , with a “1” standing between the minus sign and the fraction.
  • The problem: the coefficient for untied ranks is , which is what the page gives if the stray “1” is read as a factor of one. Read the way a mixed number is written, , it would give , which is zero for identical rankings instead of one. Formula (A.4) on the same page reduces to the usual coefficient when there are no ties, so the intended form is not in doubt; the “1” is a typesetting remnant.
  • Evidence: Formula (A.3) on PDF page 12 (printed p. 6) of ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 (first edition, 2019-12).
  • Library behaviour: spearman_rank_correlation evaluates without ties and Formula (A.4) with them; the conformance rows hold the first to Pearson’s coefficient of the ranks and the second to scipy.stats.spearmanr (soundscape.py). No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (A.4) (the where-list of the tie counts)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (A.4) (the where-list of the tie counts)”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), A.4, the where-list under Formula (A.4), Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient for tied ranks.
  • The print: ” is the number of in tied ranks of the variable ; is the number of in tied ranks of the variable ; and are the numbers of tied ranks of the variables and ”, under and .
  • The problem: the first two definitions are not sentences (“the number of in tied ranks”) and define by itself. The sums need to be the number of values sharing the -th tied rank of ( the same for ), and , to be the number of such groups of ties in each variable, which “the numbers of tied ranks” does not say. The intended reading is the usual tie correction of Spearman’s coefficient, which is what makes (A.4) Pearson’s coefficient of the average ranks.
  • Evidence: the where-list on PDF page 13 (printed p. 7), under Formula (A.4) on PDF page 12 (printed p. 6), of ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 (first edition, 2019-12).
  • Library behaviour: spearman_rank_correlation sums over the groups of equal values of each variable, and a conformance row holds Formula (A.4) so read to scipy.stats.spearmanr on 93 real answers with heavy ties (soundscape.py). No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (B.2) ( for )

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, Formula (B.2) (xI​ for xi​)”
  • Location: Annex B (informative), B.3, the where-list under Formula (B.2), the covariance of Pearson’s correlation coefficient.
  • The print: ” is the arithmetic mean value of the array ;” with a capital , followed by ” is the arithmetic mean value of the array ;”.
  • The problem: the index is the lower-case of the sum in (B.2), , and of the line for just under it; names no array of the annex.
  • Evidence: the where-list on PDF page 15 (printed p. 9) of ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 (first edition, 2019-12).
  • Library behaviour: pearson_correlation takes as the mean of the (soundscape.py). No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, A.3 f), NOTE (exponent 3 for a cube root)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, A.3 f), NOTE (exponent 3 for a cube root)”
  • Location: Annex A (normative), A.3 f), the NOTE on the root mean cubed loudness .
  • The print: “The root mean cubed loudness (cubic mean), Nrmc, is computed by determining the mean of all loudness values raised to the power of 3 with a subsequent application of the exponent 3 as shown in the following formula: ”.
  • The problem: the text and the formula under it disagree. The formula takes the cube root of the mean of the cubes, a subsequent exponent of , which is what a cubic mean is and what returns a loudness in sone; the text says the subsequent exponent is 3, which would give the mean cube raised to the third power, , in sone to the ninth. The sentence should read “a subsequent application of the exponent 1/3”. ISO 532-1:2017, 6.4, NOTE, describes the energy mean of the loudness level in the same shape and gets it right: a power of about 3.322 and then a power law “with the exponent lg(2)”, its inverse.
  • Evidence: the NOTE and its formula on PDF page 14 (printed p. 8) of ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 (first edition, 2018-08); ISO 532-1:2017, 6.4, on PDF page 22 (printed p. 16).
  • Library behaviour: binaural_indicators computes of each ear by the formula, the cube root of the mean of the cubes of the loudness over time, and a conformance row holds it to that formula (soundscape_binaural.py). No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, C.3.2.3 against Figure C.7 (three scales in the text, four in the figure)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, C.3.2.3 against Figure C.7 (three scales in the text, four in the figure)”
  • Location: Annex C (informative), C.3.2.3, “Soundwalk data collection part 1: Assessment of the sound environment”, and Figure C.7 below it.
  • The print: the text reads “The participants should assess a site on three different five-point unipolar continuous-category scales with additional verbal labelling ranging from “not at all” to “extremely”.” The figure prints four scales: “How loud is it here?”, “How unpleasant is it here?” and “How appropriate is the sound to the surrounding?”, labelled from “not at all” to “extremely”, and “How often would you like to visit this place again?”, labelled “never”, “rarely”, “sometimes”, “often”, “very often”.
  • The problem: the text and the figure it introduces disagree on the number of scales and on their labels. Either the fourth scale belongs to Method B, and the text should say four and name its second set of labels, or it does not, and the figure should not print it. ISO/TS 12913-3:2019 B.2 and Table B.1 speak of “the five-point unipolar continuous-category scales” without a number and do not settle it.
  • Evidence: C.3.2.3 and Figure C.7 on PDF page 24 (printed p. 18) of ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 (first edition); B.2 and Table B.1 on PDF page 14 (printed p. 8) of ISO/TS 12913-3:2019.
  • Library behaviour: METHOD_B_SCALES holds the four scales of the figure, as printed, and method_b_summary takes a table of three or four of them, so a study that used either reading is summarised under its own questions (soundscape.py).
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, Figures C.2 to C.4 (“extend” for “extent”, “reponse” for “response”)

Section titled “ISO/TS 12913-2:2018, Figures C.2 to C.4 (“extend” for “extent”, “reponse” for “response”)”
  • Location: Annex C (informative), the questionnaire of Method A: the questions of Figures C.2, C.3 and C.4 and the instruction line under each.
  • The print: “To what extend do you presently hear the following four types of sounds?” (Figure C.2), “To what extend do you presently hear the following three types of sounds?” (Figure C.3), “For each of the 8 scales below, to what extend do you agree or disagree that the present surrounding sound environment is…” (Figure C.4); and “Please tick off one reponse alternative per type of sound” (Figures C.2 and C.3), “Please tick off one reponse alternative per scale” (Figure C.4).
  • The problem: “extend” is a verb; the question asks “to what extent”, which Figure C.6 of the same annex spells correctly (“Overall, to what extent is the present surrounding sound environment appropriate to the present place?”). “reponse” is a misspelling of “response”. The figures are a questionnaire meant to be put in front of participants as printed, so the slips reach the field unless the study corrects them.
  • Evidence: Figures C.2 and C.3 on PDF page 21 (printed p. 15), Figures C.4 and C.6 on PDF page 22 (printed p. 16), all of ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 (first edition).
  • Library behaviour: METHOD_A_SCALES and METHOD_A_ALTERNATIVE_PART_1 transcribe the questions and instructions as printed, misspellings included, so the table can be compared with the page; the docstring of QuestionnaireScale says a study printing its own questionnaire from it should correct them (soundscape.py).
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated