Skip to content

Errata in Vigran (2008)

These are the 3 entries of the errata registry on Vigran (2008), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Vigran, Building Acoustics (2008), Figure 8.37 caption (carpet stiffness exponent)

Section titled “Vigran, Building Acoustics (2008), Figure 8.37 caption (carpet stiffness exponent)”
  • Non-normative source (textbook).
  • Location: section 8.4.2, the caption of Figure 8.37 on printed p. 320 / pdf p. 341, which labels the predicted improvement curves of two floor coverings laid on a heavyweight floor.
  • The print: “Predicted improvement with a linear model: stiffness of carpet squares 3.2·10^6 N/m, vinyl covering 5.2·10^6 N/m.” (Vigran writes the decimal separator as a period.)
  • The problem: the carpet exponent is one order too high. The body text introducing the figure, on printed p. 321, says of the carpet squares that “we have assumed that the covering has the same stiffness as used in Figure 8.36”, and Figure 8.36 is labelled inside the plot, the same value the body text on printed p. 320 gives for it. The vinyl value in the same caption is correct.
  • Evidence: printed p. 320 states “giving a resonance frequency f0 of approximately 130 Hz with a hammer mass of 0.5 kg”, and reproduces that while is a frequency that appears nowhere in the section. The same arithmetic applied to the caption’s vinyl value gives against the “approximately 510 Hz” printed on p. 321, which fixes the formula and the hammer mass the author used. Graphically, the two dashed prediction curves of Fig. 8.37 are about two octaves apart, matching the stiffness ratio (a factor 4.03 in frequency) and not (a factor 1.27). Verified on PDF page 341 (printed p. 320) of Vigran, Building Acoustics:2008, on which both caption exponents read 6 unambiguously and the body text of the same page reads , with the surrounding argument read on PDF page 340 (printed p. 319) and PDF page 342 (printed p. 321) of the same edition.
  • Library behaviour: none needed; the library takes the covering stiffness from the user through covering_contact_stiffness, and the printed cut-off frequencies it is anchored on come from Hopkins rather than from this caption.
  • Status: unreported.

Vigran, Building Acoustics (2008), Eq. (9.18) (receiving-side coefficient)

Section titled “Vigran, Building Acoustics (2008), Eq. (9.18) (receiving-side coefficient)”
  • Location: Section 9.2.3.2, Eq. (9.18) (printed p. 339), the transmission factor of the one-dimensional suspended-ceiling plenum model after Mechel (1980).
  • The print: the denominator reads with the unprimed , while the exponent of the same expression carries the primed of Eq. (9.17).
  • The problem: the two sides of the plenum are integrated the same way. The receiving-side integral is , so the factor that normalises it must be , exactly as the source-side one is . Read literally, the printed expression is not a transmission factor at all: it carries a spurious , so it grows without bound as the plenum damping falls. Two consequences are visible with ordinary inputs (, , , , ): the model diverges as the plenum damping vanishes, giving at but only 26.48 dB at and 6.64 dB at , against the finite 40.85 dB that the derived reading returns for the same bare plenum, where the leakage term bounds the path; a plenum with no absorber at all is therefore predicted arbitrarily worse than the leak-limited value rather than equal to it. It also breaks energy conservation, returning at , and at , .
  • Evidence: with in the denominator every one of those pathologies disappears: flattens onto the leak-limited value as the damping vanishes, where the printed form keeps growing, and is bounded above by 1 because , and reduces to Vigran’s own small-attenuation result, Eq. (9.19) , whenever and are both small. With the printed the same limit picks up the factor , which diverges, so Eq. (9.18) as printed does not reduce to Eq. (9.19) at all: the two equations the book presents as a pair are inconsistent with each other. Verified on PDF page 361 (printed p. 339) of Vigran, Building Acoustics:2008, which shows the denominator carrying the unprimed while the exponent of the same expression carries the primed of Eq. (9.17).
  • Library behaviour: plenum_flanking_reduction_index in ceiling_plenum.py implements the derived in both the exponent and the denominator, with the reading documented at the formula, and rejects a transmission factor above unity rather than reporting a negative sound reduction index. Tests pin the physics the model owes (monotonicity in the damping, the bound, the size of the Eq. (9.17) leakage term at a realistic ceiling) and the one property that separates the two readings: a bare plenum no worse than the undamped Eq. (9.20) value (tests/building/prediction/test_ceiling_plenum.py).
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard). Mechel’s original 1980 paper, which Vigran reproduces, was not available to check whether the misprint originates there.

Vigran (2008), Table 3.1 (a Poisson ratio whose second endpoint has lost its decimal point)

Section titled “Vigran (2008), Table 3.1 (a Poisson ratio whose second endpoint has lost its decimal point)”
  • Location: Table 3.1, “Examples of material properties”, row “Aluminium”, column “Poisson’s ratio”, on printed page 88 (PDF page 109). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: “0.33–034”.
  • The problem: a Poisson ratio lies between and , and is not one. The row above, steel, prints its range as “0.28–0.31” with both endpoints written as decimals, and so does every other range in the column. The second endpoint of the aluminium range has lost its decimal point.
  • Evidence: Verified on PDF page 109 (printed p. 88) of Vigran, Building Acoustics (2008). The cell is legible and reads “0.33–034”; the steel cell immediately above it reads “0.28–0.31”.
  • What the library does: the cell is held as misprinted in PUBLISHED_SOLIDS and refused. The intended endpoint is easy to guess from the pattern, but the page does not print it, and this library does not finish a value the page left unfinished.
  • Status: unreported.