Skip to content

Errata in Osses, García & Kohlrausch (2016)

This is the entry of the errata registry on Osses, García & Kohlrausch (2016). The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Osses, García & Kohlrausch (2016), fluctuation-strength model, Eq. (3)

Section titled “Osses, García & Kohlrausch (2016), fluctuation-strength model, Eq. (3)”
  • Location: Eq. (3), the critical-band-rate (Bark) transformation of the excitation-pattern front-end.
  • The print: .
  • The problem: the first coefficient is the Zwicker-Terhardt with the exponent misprinted. The paper’s own anchors disprove the print: it states and (section 2.1.2) and (section 3.1), all of which require . With , instead of and the model’s 47 filter centres would span 491 Hz to 20 kHz instead of 50 Hz to 13.2 kHz.
  • Evidence: evaluation of Eq. (3) under both exponents against the paper’s printed Bark/frequency anchors. The printed section 2.1.2 range “0.5 Bark (50 Hz) to 23.5 Bark (13.2 kHz)” and the section 3.1 anchor “15 Bark (2.7 kHz)” all reproduce under the Zwicker-Terhardt (50.6 Hz, 13.07 kHz and 2.71 kHz) and none of them under the printed exponent. Verified on PDF page 4 (printed p. 4) of Osses, García & Kohlrausch, ICA:2016, with the anchors on PDF page 7 (printed p. 7) of the same paper.
  • Library behaviour: implements with a note at the formula; the carrier-frequency sweep test would catch a regression to the printed value (_fluctuation_strength.py).
  • Status: unreported (conference paper rather than a standard).