Skip to content

Errata in Norton & Karczub (2003)

These are the 5 entries of the errata registry on Norton & Karczub (2003), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Norton & Karczub, Fundamentals of Noise and Vibration Analysis for Engineers 2e (2003), Eq. (6.56)

Section titled “Norton & Karczub, Fundamentals of Noise and Vibration Analysis for Engineers 2e (2003), Eq. (6.56)”
  • Location: Section 6.6.1, Eq. (6.56), the coupling loss factor of two homogeneous plates joined by point connections (printed p. 418).
  • The print: the denominator bracket appears to the first power.
  • The problem: as printed the expression is not dimensionless. The prefactor already has the dimensions of over , i.e. unity, so the remaining ratio of the two bracketed products must be dimensionless too. That requires the sum to be squared, .
  • Evidence: the book’s own answer to problem 6.13 (printed p. 617). With the squared denominator the twelve-bolt aluminium pair gives at 125 Hz against the printed , and matches the whole 125 Hz to 2 kHz column to better than ; with the printed (unsquared) denominator the result is not a loss factor at all. Verified on PDF page 438 (printed p. 418) of Norton & Karczub, Fundamentals of Noise and Vibration Analysis for Engineers 2e:2003.
  • Library behaviour: point_connection_coupling_loss_factor in _junction_transmission.py implements the squared form, with the printed column pinned by a regression test (tests/vibration/structural/test_junction_transmission.py) and a note at the formula.
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 6.13 answer (eta_21 column)

Section titled “Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 6.13 answer (eta_21 column)”
  • Location: Answers to problems, problem 6.13 (printed p. 617), the two columns of the welded and bolted tables.
  • The print: for the two aluminium plates (plate 1: 3 mm, 2.5 m × 1.2 m; plate 2: 5.5 mm, 2.0 m × 1.2 m) the answer gives, at 125 Hz, (welded) and (bolted).
  • The problem: both columns are exactly the corresponding column multiplied by . The SEA consistency relationship is (Eq. 6.8) with the flat-plate modal density of Eq. (6.25), so the correct factor is . The printed column drops the plate area ratio .
  • Evidence: the ratio of the printed columns is 1.8333 to five digits in every band of both tables, which is exactly; the columns themselves reproduce from Eqs. (6.52) to (6.56) to better than 0.7 %. Verified on PDF page 637 (printed p. 617) of Norton & Karczub 2e:2003, the page that carries both answer tables.
  • Library behaviour: the columns are used as the regression oracle; is obtained from Eq. (6.8) with the full modal densities, and a test pins the 2.292 ratio explicitly (tests/vibration/structural/test_junction_transmission.py).
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 6.10 (platform area)

Section titled “Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 6.10 (platform area)”
  • Location: Problems, problem 6.10 (printed pp. 593-594) and its answer (printed p. 617): a satellite platform coupled to an aluminium cylinder, 500 Hz octave, printed answers , and .
  • The print: the statement gives the aluminium platform as “5 mm thick and 3.5 m × 3 m”, i.e. .
  • The problem: that area is inconsistent with the three printed answers. Eq. (6.12) fixes from the printed loss factors alone, whereas the stated geometry with the printed velocities (27.2 and 13.2 mm/s) gives 7.88. The energy ratio is independent of the modal densities and of the wave speed, so no choice of those can reconcile it; only the platform area can. The area the answers imply is 8.73 , which is minus the footprint of the cylinder that Fig. P6.10 shows passing through the platform.
  • Evidence: with the inversion of Eqs. (6.15), (6.8) and (6.10) returns , and , i.e. all three printed answers within 0.4 %; the cylinder’s own energy and modal density come out unchanged either way. Verified on PDF page 613 (printed p. 593), which carries the statement and its dimensions, and PDF page 637 (printed p. 617), which carries the three answers, of Norton & Karczub 2e:2003.
  • Library behaviour: power_injection_clf in experimental_sea.py implements the inversion as published; the regression test uses the free platform area and documents the discrepancy (tests/vibration/structural/test_experimental_sea.py).
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 3.14 (structural loss factor)

Section titled “Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), problem 3.14 (structural loss factor)”
  • Location: Problems, problem 3.14 (printed p. 580) and its answer (printed p. 611): the octave-band transmission loss of a 20 mm particle board panel.
  • The print: the statement gives the panel a structural loss factor of ”~”; the answer gives 27 dB at 8 kHz and 38.6 dB at 16 kHz.
  • The problem: those two values are above the panel’s critical frequency (4885 Hz for Appendix 4 particle board, ) and therefore follow Cremer’s Eq. (3.110), which contains . With the equation gives 37.0 dB and 48.5 dB, ten decibels above the printed answers; with it gives 27.0 dB and 38.5 dB.
  • Evidence: the 10 dB offset is exactly one decade of , and the frequency dependence of the printed pair independently fixes against the Appendix 4 value of 4885 Hz. The eight values below coincidence reproduce exactly from Eq. (3.104) and do not involve . The discrepancy is a decade in a printed exponent, so the two figures were read as images rather than through the text layer. Verified on PDF page 600 (printed p. 580) and PDF page 631 (printed p. 611) of Norton & Karczub 2e (2003).
  • Library behaviour: the regression test uses , the value the printed answers require (tests/building/prediction/test_panel_transmission.py).
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), Appendix 4 (the Young’s modulus of cork, three powers of ten too large)

Section titled “Norton & Karczub 2e (2003), Appendix 4 (the Young’s modulus of cork, three powers of ten too large)”
  • Location: Appendix 4, “Physical properties of some common substances”, part A “Solids”, row “Cork”, on printed page 605 (PDF page 625). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: Cork: density kg/m, Young’s modulus Pa, a dash in both the Poisson ratio and the bar speed cells, bulk speed m/s, product of critical frequency and thickness .
  • The problem: Pa is the modulus of a glass, and it is the value the same table prints for Glass (Pyrex) two rows below. The rest of the cork row contradicts it: with the density and the speed the row prints, Pa, a factor of about a thousand smaller. The table’s own last column agrees with the m/s rather than with the modulus: it is with m/s, and , which is what the page prints. The two other foamed or cellular solids in the same block, polyurethane and polystyrene, are printed at and Pa. The mantissa is consistent with the row and the exponent is not.
  • Evidence: Verified on PDF page 625 (printed p. 605) of Norton & Karczub, Fundamentals of Noise and Vibration Analysis for Engineers 2e (2003). The two moduli, cork’s and Pyrex’s, are legible and identical on the page; the cork row’s density, speed and last column are equally legible and consistent with each other.
  • What the library does: the cell is held as misprinted in PUBLISHED_SOLIDS, so the row keeps what the book prints and refuses to serve it as a modulus. The page does not print the exponent it meant, so no corrected value is supplied. The rest of the row is served normally.
  • Status: unreported.