Skip to content

Errata in NMFS (2024)

This is the entry of the errata registry on NMFS (2024). The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

NMFS (2024) Updated Technical Guidance v3.0, Table 5 / Table ES2 (otariid C)

Section titled “NMFS (2024) Updated Technical Guidance v3.0, Table 5 / Table ES2 (otariid C)”

Regulatory guidance document, not a standard.

  • Location: Table 5 (printed p. 25), repeated as Table ES2 (printed p. 3) and again as Table 8 (printed p. 35): the auditory weighting parameter of the otariid pinniped in-water group (OW / OCW).
  • The print: .
  • The problem: the correct value is 1.36 dB. NMFS states so itself in the table’s own footnote: “During the public comment period, an error was identified with the Navy’s rounding, where this value should be 1.36, instead of 1.37. Because this is such a minor error and to remain consistent with the Navy, NMFS decided rely upon the value the Navy originally provided.” The document therefore knowingly publishes the wrong digit.
  • Evidence: independent recomputation of from its own definition, the negated peak of , with the same row’s parameters , , , : , which rounds to 1.36. The published weighted TTS onset of the same row ( with ) is unaffected by the third digit. The same recomputation reproduces every other row of the table to the printed two decimals, so the OW row is the only one that does not round from its own parameters. Verified on PDF page 36 (printed p. 25), PDF page 14 (printed p. 3) and PDF page 46 (printed p. 35) of NMFS Updated Technical Guidance v3.0:2024, all three carrying 1.37 with the identical footnote.
  • Library behaviour: bioacoustics/weighting.py implements 1.36 and keeps the printed 1.37 available as WeightingParameters.c_db_as_printed, so an assessment that must reproduce the published table verbatim still can. Pinned by test_nmfs_2024_otariid_c_uses_the_corrected_1_36.
  • Status: unreported (the issuing body has already documented it).