Skip to content

Errata in Medwin & Clay (1998)

These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on Medwin & Clay (1998), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Medwin & Clay, Fundamentals of Acoustical Oceanography (1998), Eq. (3.4.30) (boric-acid coefficient)

Section titled “Medwin & Clay, Fundamentals of Acoustical Oceanography (1998), Eq. (3.4.30) (boric-acid coefficient)”
  • Location: the Francois-Garrison boric-acid term as transcribed by the textbook, Eq. (3.4.30), printed p. 110. An earlier revision of this entry cited Eq. 3.4.29, which is the total-absorption sum of the three terms on printed p. 109; the boric-acid block is the equation after it.
  • The print: .
  • The problem: the original paper (Francois & Garrison 1982, JASA 72, Part II, Eq. (10) and Fig. 7) prints 8.86; the digits are transposed. Only 8.86 reproduces the paper’s own Table IV: with 8.68 the boric-dominated cells at to 30 kHz sit up to below the printed totals (worst relative case 2 kHz, 10 °C, : vs the printed 0.123 dB/km).
  • Evidence: recomputation of all sampled Table IV cells under both coefficients against the paper’s printed values. Verified on PDF page 131 (printed p. 110) of Medwin & Clay, Fundamentals of Acoustical Oceanography (1998), and on PDF pages 8 and 9 (printed pp. 1886 and 1887) of Francois & Garrison (1982), JASA 72, Part II, which print the paper’s own .
  • Library behaviour: implements the paper’s 8.86 with a defensive note; the pinned Table IV set includes the boric-dominated rows.
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Medwin & Clay (1998), Eq. (3.4.30) (sound speed printed as q)

Section titled “Medwin & Clay (1998), Eq. (3.4.30) (sound speed printed as q)”
  • Location: the same Eq. (3.4.30) block, printed p. 110, its last line.
  • The print: .
  • The problem: the quantity the block needs is the sound speed , which is what the two lines above it divide by (, and in the magnesium-sulfate block on the same page). No symbol is defined anywhere in the section, so the transcribed system is not closed: a reader following the printed symbols has no value for . Francois & Garrison 1982 Part II prints the same polynomial as , introduced by “where c is the sound speed (m/s), given approximately by”.
  • Evidence: the block’s own use of two lines above, and the source paper. Verified on PDF page 131 (printed p. 110) and PDF page 130 (printed p. 109) of Medwin & Clay (1998), and of PDF page 8 (printed p. 1886) of Francois & Garrison 1982 Part II (JASA 72).
  • Library behaviour: unaffected; the absorption model takes the sound speed from the same polynomial under the name c.
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).