Errata in ISO 2631
This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO 2631-5:2018. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 2631-5:2018, Annex C worked examples (male displayed formula, female R)
Section titled “ISO 2631-5:2018, Annex C worked examples (male displayed formula, female R)”-
Location: Annex C: the displayed male worked example (82 kg male, , printed p. 19) and NOTE 5 (64 kg female, , printed p. 20).
-
The print: (a) the male example is displayed as
and (b) NOTE 5 states for the female case.
-
The problem: two independent defects. (a) The displayed male formula omits the term that normative Formula (C.3) puts in the denominator, and that the same annex fixes at in the sentence that follows the where-list of Formula (C.3). Evaluated exactly as displayed the sum gives , which prints as 1.15, not the printed 1.22; restoring the missing term gives 1.2168 with the printed and 1.2177 with the exact , i.e. the printed 1.22 either way. The printed result is therefore right and the printed formula is not. (b) Exact recomputation of Formula (C.3) with NOTE 5’s own inputs (, age coefficient 0.039, , , ) gives , which rounds to 0.96; the same code reproduces the male example exactly, and the note’s matches the exact 1.3992, so the discrepancy is confined to the last digit of the printed female .
-
Evidence: term-by-term recomputation of the C.3 sum under both readings of the denominator, with the male example as the discriminator: the printed 1.22 is reachable only with , and 1.15 only without it. Verified on PDF pages 23 (printed p. 17), 24 (printed p. 18), 25 (printed p. 19) and 26 (printed p. 20) of ISO 2631-5:2018.
-
Library behaviour: implements Formula (C.3) as written, with ; the male anchor pins 1.22 and the female test anchor keeps the printed 0.97 with a tolerance that documents the recomputed 0.9621.
-
Status: unreported.