Skip to content

Errata in ISO 13474

These are the 3 entries of the errata registry on ISO 13474:2009, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2 (the level of each class credited to Equations (7) and (8))

Section titled “ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2 (the level of each class credited to Equations (7) and (8))”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), A.2, the paragraph above Table A.3 that says how its levels were obtained.
  • The print: “For each octave band, the sound exposure level at location A was calculated using Equations (7) and (8). From this, the A-weighted sound exposure level for each excess-attenuation class was determined.”
  • The problem: Equations (7) and (8) are the long-term average single-event sound exposure level and rating level, dB, with added in the exponent of Equation (8): one number summed over every class, from levels already weighted in frequency, with no octave band and no class left in it. The paragraph describes a band level for each excess-attenuation class and then the A-weighted level of each class drawn from it, which are Equation (4), , and Equation (5). The annex itself uses Equation (7) one step later, for LT1, a single value printed on Figure A.3 that it says was “calculated using Equation (7)”. The cross-reference should read Equations (4) and (5).
  • Evidence: the paragraph read on PDF page 39 (printed p. 31), Equation (4) on PDF page 15 (printed p. 7), Equation (5) on PDF page 16 (printed p. 8), Equations (7) and (8) on PDF page 17 (printed p. 9) and the LT1 sentence on PDF page 42 (printed p. 34), all of BS ISO 13474:2009, the UK implementation of ISO 13474:2009 (first edition, 2009-06-15).
  • Library behaviour: the levels of Table A.3 are taken as printed; frequency_weighted_sel evaluates Equation (5) and long_term_sel Equations (7) and (8) (exposure_distribution.py), each under the equation its clause gives it. No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2 (the shift of Equation (22) printed as 1.04 dB)

Section titled “ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2 (the shift of Equation (22) printed as 1.04 dB)”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), A.2, the paragraph below Figure A.1 that spreads the class density for turbulence.
  • The print: the paragraph opens with “a normal distribution having a standard deviation equal to 5 dB” and continues “In this example, the mean value was shifted by an amount, Δμ, equal to 1,04 dB [from Equation (22)]”; Figure A.3 repeats dB.
  • The problem: Equation (22) is the mean of a lognormal variable and evaluates to , which is dB at dB. dB is its value at dB ( dB), a standard deviation the annex does not use. The rest of the annex was computed with dB. The shift keeps the energetic mean of every subclass at its centre, which is why the printed LT2 of 37.0 dB agrees with the printed LT1 of 37.0 dB; with dB and dB every level of the spread distribution moves up by dB, LT2 reads 38.8 dB, the peak of Figure A.2 moves from about 30.5 dB to 32.3 dB, and reads 33.3 dB against the printed 31.5 dB.
  • Evidence: the paragraph read on PDF page 42 (printed p. 34), Equation (22) on PDF page 21 (printed p. 13), Figures A.2 and A.3 on PDF pages 43 and 44 (printed pp. 35 and 36), all of BS ISO 13474:2009, the UK implementation of ISO 13474:2009 (first edition, 2009-06-15). Every value was recomputed from Table A.3 on PDF page 40 (printed p. 32) of the same document.
  • Library behaviour: the shift is Equation (22) in closed form, turbulence_level_shift, dB at 5 dB, and it is not a parameter a caller can set. The conformance check “ISO 13474:2009 Equation (22)” holds it against the printed integral evaluated by quadrature, and “ISO 13474:2009 Equation (A.4), Figure A.3” holds LT2 at the printed 37.0 dB.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2, Figure A.3 (exceedance levels that are not the roots of Equation (25))

Section titled “ISO 13474:2009, Annex A.2, Figure A.3 (exceedance levels that are not the roots of Equation (25))”
  • Location: Annex A (informative), Figure A.3, the exceedance levels printed beside the cumulative curve.
  • The print: dB, dB, dB, dB and dB, beside dB.
  • The problem: Equation (24) defines the probability that the level exceeds as and Equation (25) the -percent exceedance level as its root. On the distribution of Table A.4 spread as A.2 describes, they give 21.6; 31.5; 40.5; 43.0 and 47.5 dB: agrees and the other four print 0.1 dB to 0.5 dB higher, the more so the rarer the level. The annex does not say how it computed them. One reading is consistent with the print: a cumulative curve formed from 15 dB, where the drawn curves of Figures A.2 and A.3 begin (their axes start at 10 dB), rather than from minus infinity, ; the drawn curve of Figure A.3 begins at 15 dB on the line of 1, which is what that reading draws and where Equation (24) gives 0.998. Fed the 07:00 to 19:00 column of Table A.3 as printed, which sums to 1.0004, it gives 21.69; 31.49; 40.58; 43.16 and 47.97 dB, all five to the printed digit; it then adds about 0.17 % to every exceedance, the 0.21 % of the distribution below 15 dB less the 0.04 % by which the printed column exceeds one, which moves the levels at the smallest percentages most. Fed the full-precision probabilities that reproduce Table A.4, the same reading gives 21.69; 31.49; 40.59; 43.17 and 48.05 dB, and would print 48.1 dB. The reading is therefore a hypothesis and not a reconstruction of the figure; what is established is that four of the five printed levels are not the roots of Equation (25).
  • Evidence: Figure A.3 on PDF page 44 (printed p. 36), Figure A.2 on PDF page 43 (printed p. 35) and Equations (24) and (25) on PDF page 21 (printed p. 13), all of BS ISO 13474:2009, the UK implementation of ISO 13474:2009 (first edition, 2009-06-15). The levels were recomputed from Table A.3 on PDF page 40 (printed p. 32) of the same document.
  • Library behaviour: SELDistribution.exceedance evaluates Equation (24) to infinity in closed form and SELDistribution.exceedance_level solves Equation (25) (exposure_distribution.py), so the example returns 21.6; 31.5; 40.5; 43.0 and 47.5 dB. The conformance check “ISO 13474:2009 Equation (25), Figure A.3” holds at the printed 31.5 dB; the other four printed levels have no conformance check.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated