Skip to content

Errata in EN 1793

These are the 6 entries of the errata registry on EN 1793-5:2016, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

EN 1793-5:2016, Formula (1) against Formula (4) (a gain factor that multiplies)

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, Formula (1) against Formula (4) (a gain factor that multiplies)”
  • Location: 5.2, Formula (1) and the list under it, printed folios 15 and 16 (PDF pages 17 and 18); 5.5.1, Formula (4) and the paragraph above it, printed folio 25 (PDF page 27) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • The print: Formula (1) closes the ratio of the reflected to the incident band energy with the product , and the list under it calls “the correction factor to account for a change in the amplification settings of the loudspeaker and in the sensitivity settings of the individual microphones when changing the measurement configuration from free field to in front of the sample under test or vice versa”. 5.5.1 then defines it as “the ratio between the spectrum obtained from windowing the incident component from the impulse response in front of the sample under test and the spectrum of the incident component obtained from windowing the free field impulse response”: .
  • The problem: the two formulas put the factor on the same side. In Formula (1) the reflected component comes from the record in front of the device and the incident component from the free-field record, so a gain that differs by an amplitude factor between the two configurations already multiplies the ratio by . Formula (4) measures exactly that . Multiplying by it, as Formula (1) prints, leaves in the index; dividing by it removes the change, which is what the list under Formula (1) says the factor is for. At the 20 % that 5.5.1 still accepts (), the product as printed reports the index 44 % high, where leaving the change uncorrected would have reported it 20 % high. The two other factors of Formula (1) are the right way round: puts back the spreading of the longer reflected path, and divides the loudspeaker’s output towards the microphone by its output towards the specular point.
  • Evidence: both formulas as printed, read on the page: Formula (1) on PDF page 17 (printed p. 15), its list on PDF page 18 (printed p. 16), and Formula (4) with the paragraph that defines it on PDF page 27 (printed p. 25) of BS EN 1793-5:2016. The consequence is a recomputation: synthetic records of a reflection of amplitude 0.5, with the in-front records scaled by 1.08, return 0.25 in every band when the factor divides and when it multiplies.
  • Library behaviour: reflection_index divides by and says so in its docstring. The conformance row “EN 1793-5:2016 Formulas (1) and (4) (a gain change between configurations)” and a test on the scaled records pin it.
  • Status: unreported.

EN 1793-5:2016, Table B.2 (seven expanded uncertainties a hundredth below 1.96 times the printed )

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, Table B.2 (seven expanded uncertainties a hundredth below 1.96 times the printed sR​)”
  • Location: Annex B.5 and Table B.2, printed folios 54 and 55 (PDF pages 56 and 57) of BS EN 1793-5:2016; Table A.1 on printed folio 47 (PDF page 49).
  • The print: B.5 says the uncertainty is “estimated using the values for the standard deviation of reproducibility given in Table A.1”, with “a coverage factor of 1,96” and “the maximal ones (last column of Table A.1)”. Table B.2 prints, against (High) of 0,32, 0,18, 0,12, 0,14, 0,15, 0,15 and 0,17 in the bands of 100 Hz, 125 Hz, 500 Hz, 630 Hz, 800 Hz, 1 250 Hz and 3 150 Hz, an expanded uncertainty of 0,62, 0,34, 0,23, 0,26, 0,28, 0,28 and 0,32.
  • The problem: 1.96 times the printed gives 0.63, 0.35, 0.24, 0.27, 0.29, 0.29 and 0.33 in those seven bands, a hundredth above each printed cell. The other eleven bands reproduce to the hundredth, and so does the row of (1.96 times 0.81 dB is 1.59 dB, and 7.68 dB plus or minus that is the [6.09; 9.27] dB of B.5). No single coverage factor reproduces the seven: the 100 Hz cell needs one between 1.922 and 1.953, the 125 Hz cell one between 1.861 and 1.917.
  • The likely mechanism: every one of the seven is consistent with 1.96 times an unrounded standard deviation that rounds to the printed one (0.316 prints as 0.32, and 1.96 times 0.316 is 0.619). The print does not show which values the example multiplied; if it was those, they are values the reader of Table A.1 does not have.
  • Consequence: a hundredth of the index, which is the resolution the report states it to (5.11). A laboratory following B.5 with Table A.1 as printed obtains the higher values.
  • Evidence: the two tables as printed, read on the page: Table B.2 on PDF page 57 (printed p. 55) and Table A.1 on PDF page 49 (printed p. 47) of BS EN 1793-5:2016. The rest is a recomputation from the printed cells.
  • Library behaviour: environment.reflection_index_expanded_uncertainty multiplies the values of Table A.1 as printed. The conformance row “EN 1793-5:2016 Table B.2 (expanded uncertainty per band)” checks the eleven cells that follow from them, and a test pins the other seven a hundredth above the print.
  • Status: unreported.

EN 1793-5:2016, 5.5.7 against 5.8 (a low frequency limit read against the bands two ways)

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, 5.5.7 against 5.8 (a low frequency limit read against the bands two ways)”
  • Location: 5.5.7, fifth paragraph, printed folio 33 (PDF page 35), and 5.8, the paragraph on other purposes, the third after the list under Formula (12), printed folio 43 (PDF page 45) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • The print: 5.5.7: the qualification sample of 4 m by 4 m gives “a low frequency limit for the reflection index … of about 160 Hz at microphone 2, 170 Hz at microphone 5 and 220 Hz at microphone 8 …, i.e. using the two window lengths specified in 5.5.5 measurements are valid down to the 200 Hz one-third octave band”. 5.8: “for a 3,5 m high barrier the single number rating of sound reflection is (400 - 5 000 Hz), because 300 Hz is the lowest frequency applicable to all microphones and this invalidates the measurements in the 315 one-third octave band and below”.
  • The problem: the first example keeps a band whose centre, 200 Hz, lies below the limit of one of its microphones, 220 Hz; the second drops a band whose centre, 315 Hz, lies above the limit, 300 Hz. No single rule relating a limit to a band gives both: against the centre, the 4 m sample loses its 200 Hz band; against the lower band edge (178 Hz and 282 Hz), it loses it as well; against the upper band edge (224 Hz and 355 Hz), the 3.5 m barrier keeps its 315 Hz band.
  • Consequence: the lowest reliable band of Formula (12) cannot be derived from a low frequency limit by the rule the clause illustrates, because the two illustrations disagree.
  • Evidence: both sentences as printed, read on the page: PDF page 35 (printed p. 33) and PDF page 45 (printed p. 43) of BS EN 1793-5:2016. The band edges are the base-ten one-third octave edges, .
  • Library behaviour: sound_reflection_rating and reflection_index take the lowest reliable band from the caller, 200 Hz by default, which is what 5.5.7 states for the qualification sample and what Annex B uses; reflection_low_frequency_limit reports the limit of each microphone and leaves the choice of band to the report, which states both: the low frequency limit by 5.11 n), and the lowest reliable band used in the single number by 5.11 q).
  • Status: unreported.

EN 1793-5:2016, Table 1 against Formula (7) (what is the length of)

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, Table 1 against Formula (7) (what TW,BH​ is the length of)”
  • Location: Table 1, the row of , printed folio 14 (PDF page 16); 5.5.5, NOTE 1 and Formula (7), printed folio 31 (PDF page 33) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • The print: Table 1: ” Length of the Blackman-Harris trailing edge of the Adrienne temporal window”. NOTE 1: “A four-term full Blackman-Harris window of length is:” Formula (7), with .
  • The problem: Formula (7) rises from nearly zero to 1 over the first half of and falls back over the second, so read with the length of the trailing edge in it, it draws a whole bell over those 2.22 ms rather than the fall that 5.5.5 describes. The edges of the Adrienne window are halves of Formula (7), each over a full window twice its own length, which is the reading NOTE 1 gives and Table 1 does not.
  • Evidence: the row and the note as printed, read on the page: PDF page 16 (printed p. 14) and PDF page 33 (printed p. 31) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • Library behaviour: adrienne_reflection_window takes each edge as a half of Formula (7) over twice the edge’s length, which gives the window Figure 13 draws; the conformance row “EN 1793-5:2016 5.5.5 and 5.5.1 (the three Adrienne windows)” checks the three lengths of each window. No number changes with the reading of the row.
  • Status: unreported.

EN 1793-5:2016, 5.5.5 (“microphones 1 to 3, microphones 4 to 6 and microphones 1 to 9”)

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, 5.5.5 (“microphones 1 to 3, microphones 4 to 6 and microphones 1 to 9”)”
  • Location: 5.5.5, last paragraph, printed folio 32 (PDF page 34) of BS EN 1793-5:2016; the test report template of Annex B.1, item (m), printed folio 49 (PDF page 51).
  • The print: 5.5.5: “different window lengths for microphones 1 to 3, microphones 4 to 6 and microphones 1 to 9 may be used”. Annex B.1 (m): “Adrienne temporal window (State length for each microphone height)”, followed by “Length for microphones 1–3”, “Length for microphones 4–6” and “Length for microphones 7–9”.
  • The problem: the three groups of 5.5.5 overlap, since microphones 1 to 9 include the other six, and they leave the bottom row without a group of its own. The template of the same standard names the rows of the grid, 1 to 3, 4 to 6 and 7 to 9, one window length per microphone height; the bottom row is the one the ground reflection reaches first (5.5.7), so it is the one a reduced sample most needs a window of its own for. “1 to 9” reads as a misprint for “7 to 9”.
  • Evidence: the paragraph and the template as printed, read on the page: PDF page 34 (printed p. 32) and PDF page 51 (printed p. 49) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • Library behaviour: reflection_index takes one window length per microphone, so the three rows of the template, or any other split, can be given. No number changes with the reading.
  • Status: unreported.

EN 1793-5:2016, Figure 15 Key (a distance from the loudspeaker named , and a garbled item B)

Section titled “EN 1793-5:2016, Figure 15 Key (a distance from the loudspeaker named dM​, and a garbled item B)”
  • Location: 5.6.2.3, the Key of Figure 15, printed folio 38 (PDF page 40); Table 1, printed folio 13 (PDF page 15) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • The print: Key item 1: “Distance from the loudspeaker front panel to the reference plane [m]”. Key item B: “reference position midway and B of the sample under test”. Table 1: ” Horizontal distance from the source and microphone reference plane to the measurement grid; it is equal to = 0,25 m” and ” Horizontal distance from the front panel of the loudspeaker to the source and microphone reference plane; it is equal to: = 1,50 m”.
  • The problem: item 1 puts the words of one distance to the symbol of another. The distance from the loudspeaker front panel to the reference plane is , 1.50 m; is the 0.25 m from the plane to the grid, and that is what the dimension marked 1 spans in Figure 15 (a), from the microphones A, B and C to the dashed reference plane, with no loudspeaker drawn. The drawing and the symbol agree with Table 1; the words do not. Item B names B inside its own definition and has lost words: the caption of Figure 15 (a) calls B the position “midway”, between the most protruding part (A) and the less protruding one (C).
  • Consequence: none numerically, since Table 1 and 3.14 fix . A reader who takes the key at its word would read as the 1.50 m of the loudspeaker rather than the 0.25 m of the grid.
  • Evidence: the key, the drawing and Table 1 as printed, read on the page: PDF page 40 (printed p. 38) and PDF page 15 (printed p. 13) of BS EN 1793-5:2016.
  • Library behaviour: none required; no value is read from Figure 15. REFLECTION_SOURCE_DISTANCE_M and REFLECTION_MICROPHONE_DISTANCE_M in barrier_reflection carry = 1.50 m and = 0.25 m as Table 1 defines them.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated