Errata in DIN 45681
These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on DIN 45681:2005-03, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
DIN 45681:2005-03, Anhang I, Tabelle I.6, row “6 FG”
Section titled “DIN 45681:2005-03, Anhang I, Tabelle I.6, row “6 FG””- Location: Anhang I, Beispiel I.2 (combustion engine, spectrum ), Tabelle I.6, the combined row “6 FG” for the three tones ( / / , tone levels / / ).
- The print: together with (with , , at ).
- The problem: the two cells contradict each other. The printed only reproduces from the plain Formula (17) energy sum of the three tone levels (): . The printed is that same sum less exactly , and taken at face value it would give .
- Evidence: recomputation from the printed per-tone levels of Tabelle I.6. The offset is the discriminator and it is a constant, not a deduplication: , and is , the standard’s own Hanning effective-bandwidth correction (clause 5.3.2). The same offset appears in the “5 FG” row of Tabelle I.10 (printed p. 46), where the two member tones at and have and , sum to , and are printed as , lower, and there the printed follows the printed exactly (), so the Tabelle I.10 row is internally consistent and the Tabelle I.6 row is not. The third combined row, “2 FG” of the same Tabelle I.6, carries no offset at all: its three member levels / / sum to against a printed , and its follows. A previous revision of this entry attributed the cell to the Anmerkung 2 shared-line deduplication; that diagnosis is unsupported, because a deduplication removes an arbitrary amount of energy while all the offsets observed here are the same 1.76 dB. Verified on PDF page 41 (printed p. 41) and PDF page 46 (printed p. 46) of DIN 45681:2005-03.
- Library behaviour:
combined_tone_levelfollows Anmerkung 2 (shared lines counted once), which reproduces the printed “2 FG” oracle; for the “6 FG” row only the chain is pinned, with the contradiction recorded intests/reference_data/. - Status: unreported.
DIN 45681:2005-03, Anhang I, Tabellen I.2 and I.10 (wrong spectrum index in a column header)
Section titled “DIN 45681:2005-03, Anhang I, Tabellen I.2 and I.10 (wrong spectrum index in a column header)”- Location: Anhang I, the column headers of Tabelle I.2 (printed p. 37, spectrum ) and Tabelle I.10 (printed p. 46, spectrum ).
- The print: every column of Tabelle I.2 is subscripted with the spectrum
index 2 (
f_T 2,k,f_1 2,k,f_2 2,k,L_S 2,k,L_T 2,k,L_G 2,k,a_v 2,k,u_2,k) except the audibility column, which is headedΔL_1,k. Every column of Tabelle I.10 is subscripted 24 (f_T 24,k,ΔL 24,k,f_1 24,k,f_2 24,k,L_S 24,k,L_T 24,k,L_G 24,k,u 24,k) except the masking column, which is headeda_v 1,k. - The problem: both tables carry the spectrum index of the first
spectrum in one column. Tabelle I.2’s own caption reads “des zweiten
Spektrums (j = 2)” and Tabelle I.10’s “des 24. Spektrums (j = 24)”, and the
body values belong to those spectra: the column of Tabelle I.2 is
the audibility of the tones ( at
, which the Anmerkung below the table calls “die
maßgebliche Differenz ΔL_2”), and the column of Tabelle I.10 is the
masking index of the tones. The index 1 is right in exactly one
table of the annex, Tabelle I.6, which is the table of Beispiel I.2
and carries both
ΔL_1,kanda_v 1,klegitimately. - Evidence: the tables’ own captions, their neighbouring column subscripts, and the Anmerkung under each. Verified on PDF page 37 (printed p. 37), PDF page 46 (printed p. 46), and PDF page 41 (printed p. 41) of DIN 45681:2005-03.
- Library behaviour: none needed; the numbers are unaffected. The regression fixtures index both tables by their caption’s spectrum.
- Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects