Skip to content

Errata in Bies, Hansen & Howard (2017)

These are the 4 entries of the errata registry on Bies, Hansen & Howard (2017), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Bies, Hansen & Howard, Engineering Noise Control 5e (2017), Eq. (8.141)

Section titled “Bies, Hansen & Howard, Engineering Noise Control 5e (2017), Eq. (8.141)”
  • Location: Section 8.9.1, Eq. (8.141) (printed p. 461), the transmission loss of a muffler from the elements of its total four-pole matrix.
  • The print: i.e. with the impedance ratio weighting and its inverse weighting .
  • The problem: the source the equation itself cites (Munjal, Acoustics of Ducts and Mufflers 2e, Eq. (3.27), p. 105) carries the overall prefactor (equivalently inside a form) with unweighted and on . As printed, Eq. (8.141) fails the sudden-expansion limit: a zero-length element () between and is a sudden area expansion with the classic (), but the printed equation gives . Reading the ratios as an overall prefactor instead is also wrong: it gives 6.532 dB on the same oracle and violates reciprocity ( vs -0.70 dB for an expansion chamber between unequal pipes; a negative TL for a passive element). The misprint is invisible whenever the inlet and outlet areas are equal, where every variant reduces to Eq. (8.148).
  • Evidence: numeric evaluation of the zero-length identity element and of an unequal-port expansion chamber under the printed form, the inverted prefactor and Munjal Eq. (3.27); only Munjal’s form reproduces the sudden-expansion classic (0.512 dB, both directions) and is reciprocal.
  • Library behaviour: transmission_loss in silencers.py implements Munjal Eq. (3.27), with the sudden-expansion limit and TL reciprocity pinned by regression tests (tests/noise_control/test_silencers.py) and a defensive note at the formula.
  • Status: unreported (textbook rather than a standard).

Bies 5e (2017), Table C.1 (three speeds that do not follow from the two columns they are said to be calculated from)

Section titled “Bies 5e (2017), Table C.1 (three speeds that do not follow from the two columns they are said to be calculated from)”
  • Location: Table C.1, “Properties of materials”, the rows “Brick” and “Cork” on printed page 719 (PDF page 748) and “Plywood (fir)” on printed page 720 (PDF page 749), against the text on printed page 717 (PDF page 746). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: printed page 717 says “The speed of sound values in column 4 of Table C.1 were calculated from the values in columns 2 and 3”, which are the Young’s modulus in N/m2 and the density in kg/m3. The three rows give, in that order, = 24 and = 2000 with a speed of 3650 m/s; = 0,1 and = 250 with 500 m/s; and = 8,3 and = 600 with 4540 m/s.
  • The problem: on those cells gives 3464, 632 and 3719 m/s. The printed speeds are 5.4 per cent above, 20.9 per cent below and 22.1 per cent above what the two columns beside them give.
  • Evidence: the same expression reproduces the rest of the table. Of the eighty-seven rows that print both the modulus and the density as single values, seventy-nine agree within 1 per cent and eighty-four within 3, with a median offset of 0.03 per cent, across speeds from 190 to 27000 m/s. Only these three fall outside, which is the signature of a misprinted cell rather than of a looser method than the page describes. Which cell is misprinted cannot be told from the page: 4540 m/s would follow from a modulus of 12.4 rather than 8.3, and 500 m/s from a density of 400 rather than 250. Verified against the page as printed on PDF pages 748 and 749 (printed pp. 719 and 720) of Bies, Hansen and Howard (2017), Engineering Noise Control, fifth edition.
  • Consequence for the book’s own tables: three cells. Nothing else in the document computes with them.
  • Library behaviour: the catalogue holds the three columns as printed and derives nothing over them, and each of the three rows carries the disagreement in its note. The test test_three_rows_do_not_follow_from_their_own_two_columns in tests/solids/test_catalogue.py pins the three, and test_the_rest_of_the_table_reproduces_to_three_per_cent pins the eighty-four that do follow, which is what makes the three a defect.
  • Status: not reported.

Bies 5e (2017), Table C.2 (four molar masses that do not belong to the gas in the row)

Section titled “Bies 5e (2017), Table C.2 (four molar masses that do not belong to the gas in the row)”
  • Location: Table C.2, “Molecular weights and ratios of specific heats for some commonly used gases”, the rows “Ammonia”, “Fluorine”, “Freon 22” and “Nitric oxide” on printed page 722 (PDF page 751). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: the four rows give, in the column headed “Molecular weight, kg/mole”, 0.01730, 0.01900, 0.08047 and 0.06301.
  • The problem: the molar mass of a gas follows from the molecule the row names, and none of these four does. Ammonia is NH at 17.031 g/mol, not 17.30. Fluorine gas is F at 37.996 g/mol, and 19.00 is the atomic mass of one fluorine atom. Freon 22 is CHClF at 86.465 g/mol, not 80.47. Nitric oxide is NO at 30.006 g/mol, and 63.01 is the molar mass of nitric acid, HNO.
  • Evidence: the rest of the table settles that these are misprints rather than a looser convention. Thirty-five of the thirty-seven rows name a molecule whose formula mass can be computed; the two that do not are the mixtures, air and natural gas. Of those thirty-five, thirty-one reproduce their formula mass to better than 0.05 per cent, and the two that are further out are further out only because the page rounds: helium at 4.00 against 4.0026 is 0.07 per cent low and hydrogen at 2.02 against 2.016 is 0.20 per cent high, both of them the last printed digit. So the table’s own precision is two parts in a thousand, against which the four exceptions are 1.6, 6.9, 50.0 and 110.0 per cent out. Two of them land exactly on a different species, which is what a copying slip looks like: 19.00 is atomic fluorine to 0.01 per cent and 63.01 is HNO to 0.003 per cent, the same accuracy the correct rows have. The ratio of specific heats printed beside each of the four points the same way: 1.36 for fluorine and 1.40 for nitric oxide are diatomic values, so the rows mean F and NO whatever their mass column says. An independent table of the same genre agrees on both counts: the Masoneilan Control Valve Sizing Handbook (Baker Hughes, BHMN-19540C, 2022), which tabulates the same two quantities for the same purpose, prints “Fluorine, F” with a ratio of specific heats of 1.36 on its page 19 and “Ammonia, NH” with a molecular weight of 17.0 on its page 20. Verified against the page as printed on PDF page 751 (printed p. 722) of Bies, Hansen and Howard (2017), Engineering Noise Control, fifth edition, and on pages 19 and 20 of the Masoneilan handbook.
  • Consequence for the book’s own tables: four cells. Nothing else in the document computes with them; the table is offered for the control valve noise of Section 10.8, where the gas is chosen by the reader. A reader who did take one of the four would get a speed of sound 0.8 per cent low for ammonia, 3.7 per cent high for Freon 22, 41.4 per cent high for fluorine and 31.0 per cent low for nitric oxide, since .
  • Library behaviour: the catalogue holds the row and its ratio of specific heats, and refuses the molar mass rather than serving it: reading it raises, naming the cell, quoting what the page prints and pointing here. The tests test_a_cell_the_errata_names_is_not_served_as_a_value and test_the_refusal_quotes_the_printed_number_and_points_at_the_registry in tests/fluids/test_gas_catalogue.py pin both halves, and test_no_other_cell_of_either_table_is_called_wrong keeps the claim from spreading to a fifth row.
  • Status: not reported.

Bies 5e (2017), Table C.2 (two ratios of specific heats that no gas can have)

Section titled “Bies 5e (2017), Table C.2 (two ratios of specific heats that no gas can have)”
  • Location: Table C.2, “Molecular weights and ratios of specific heats for some commonly used gases”, the rows “Hydrogen fluoride” and “Octane” on printed page 722 (PDF page 751). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: the column headed “Ratio of specific heats, ” gives 0.97 for hydrogen fluoride and 1.66 for octane.
  • The problem: the column is the ratio of specific heats, which its own heading names as such and which the table exists to feed into the control valve procedure the appendix points at, “particularly useful for calculating control valve noise (see Section 10.8)”. For any substance in a stable single phase , so and a printed 0.97 is outside what the quantity can be. That is a statement about and not about every exponent an engineer might write as : the real-gas isentropic exponent of a strongly associating vapour, which is what hydrogen fluoride is, can fall below 1, but it is a different quantity from the one this column names and not the one the procedure downstream wants. The octane cell is outside the column in the other direction: for an ideal gas where counts the active degrees of freedom, and always, so with equality only for a monatomic one. Octane is CH, twenty-six atoms, with three rotational degrees of freedom on top of the three translational ones before any vibration is counted, which caps it at and puts it near 1.05 in practice. That bound is an ideal-gas one, and a real fluid does pass 5/3 near its critical point; what rules out reading the cell that way is that this is an ideal-gas column, printed against ideal molar masses, giving one value per gas rather than one per state.
  • Evidence: the column is otherwise a clean function of molecular complexity, which is what makes the two exceptions visible. The three monatomic gases print 1.64 to 1.67, the diatomic ones 1.31 to 1.41, and the polyatomic ones fall away with size down to 1.05. Octane’s two nearest neighbours in that progression are in the same table and one carbon apart: n-heptane prints 1.05 and pentane 1.06, so the table itself says what an alkane of this size does. Hydrogen fluoride’s neighbours are the other diatomic rows, and hydrogen chloride, the next halide down, prints 1.41. Outside the book, the Masoneilan Control Valve Sizing Handbook (Baker Hughes, BHMN-19540C, 2022) prints 1.05 for octane in the same column on its page 19, between 1.66 for helium and 1.07 for pentane, so the progression is not a habit of one author. Verified against the page as printed on PDF page 751 (printed p. 722) of Bies, Hansen and Howard (2017), Engineering Noise Control, fifth edition, with both cells re-read at six times magnification: 0.97 and 1.66 are what the page prints, with no digit in doubt.
  • Consequence for the book’s own tables: two cells. A reader taking the octane row would get a speed of sound 26.0 per cent high; the hydrogen fluoride row cannot be used at all, because a speed of sound computed from a below 1 is not the speed of anything.
  • Library behaviour: the catalogue holds the row and its molar mass, and refuses the ratio rather than serving it, the same way and with the same message as the four molar masses above. The independent guard is phonometry.fluids.ideal_gas, which refuses a ratio at or below 1 whoever passes it, and test_a_ratio_of_specific_heats_at_or_below_one_is_refused in tests/fluids/test_gas.py pins that.
  • Status: not reported.
Edit page

Published , updated