Errata in ASHRAE (2019)
This is the entry of the errata registry on ASHRAE (2019). The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ASHRAE (2019) HVAC Applications Handbook, Chapter 49, folio 49.31 (the sentence that introduces the break-in tables swaps two of them)
Section titled “ASHRAE (2019) HVAC Applications Handbook, Chapter 49, folio 49.31 (the sentence that introduces the break-in tables swaps two of them)”- Location: Chapter 49, “Noise and Vibration Control”, the paragraph printed under Equation (24) on printed page 49.31 (PDF page 915), and the titles of Tables 32 and 33 printed on that same page. Non-normative source: a design handbook.
- The print: the paragraph reads “Values for TL_in for rectangular ducts are given in Table 32, for round ducts in Table 33, and for flat oval ducts in Table 34 (Cummings 1983, 1985).” The two tables it names first are titled, on the same page, “Table 32 Experimentally Measured TL_in Versus Frequency for Circular Ducts” and “Table 33 TL_in Versus Frequency for Rectangular Ducts”.
- The problem: the first two tables are named the wrong way round. Table 32 is the circular one and Table 33 the rectangular one, and the sentence says the opposite; the third, flat oval, is right. What the tables print settles it against the sentence rather than against the titles. Table 32 is indexed by a Diameter and a Length, which is what a round duct has and what no rectangular one is given anywhere in the chapter, and it prints the marks of a measured table, a lower bound and a parenthesised value, under the note that explains them; Table 33 is indexed by a Duct Size of two sides in millimetres and prints an 8 kHz column, which in this chapter only the two rectangular tables do. The companion sentence for breakout on folio 49.29 pairs the same three shapes with Tables 29, 30 and 31 in the order rectangular, round, flat oval, and there the three printed titles agree with it. Only this sentence is wrong.
- Evidence: Verified on PDF page 915 (printed p. 49.31) of ASHRAE (2019), 2019 ASHRAE handbook: Heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning applications (SI ed.), Chapter 49, and against the breakout paragraph on PDF page 913 (printed p. 49.29) of the same chapter. Two readers transcribed the page independently and both read the sentence and the two titles as they are quoted here.
- What the library does: nothing, and nothing is needed: the cross
reference is a label the library never reads. Every row of Tables 32, 33 and
34 in
PUBLISHED_DUCT_TRANSMISSION_LOSSis filed under the table whose own printed title it was read from, andshapecarries the word that title uses. That sentence is the only credit the chapter gives those three tables, so each of their rows quotes it verbatim inattributed_to["table"]and records there that its first two tables are the wrong way round. - Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects