Skip to content

Errata in Allard & Atalla (2009)

These are the 8 entries of the errata registry on Allard & Atalla (2009), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e (2009), Eq. (6.85)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e (2009), Eq. (6.85)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Sect. 6.5.2 (printed p. 123), the second form of the shear-wave velocity ratio .
  • The print: , offered as an alternative to Eq. (6.84), .
  • The problem: the two printed forms are not equal. Substituting the shear wavenumber of Eq. (6.83), , into the printed Eq. (6.85) gives , which is Eq. (6.84) multiplied by the spurious factor . The denominator should read .
  • Evidence: the book’s own derivation. Eq. (6.80), printed p. 122, is , so and therefore . With that reading the two forms agree identically wherever is non-zero; at the corrected quotient is while Eq. (6.84) stays defined and gives , which is the value to use there. The printed form instead differs from Eq. (6.84) by the factor , so it coincides with it only where that ratio is exactly 0 or exactly 1. With those two cases ask for and , both real; the effective density of a lossy porous medium is complex, so neither is ever met. Verified on PDF page 132 (printed p. 123) of Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009, which carries both printed forms, and on the facing page for Eq. (6.80).
  • Library behaviour: biot_waves implements Eq. (6.84) as printed, and test_shear_velocity_ratio_matches_the_corrected_second_printed_form checks it against the corrected Eq. (6.85) over four decades of frequency, and also asserts that the form exactly as printed disagrees.
  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Eq. (11.48) and Table 11.1 (poroelastic layer)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Eq. (11.48) and Table 11.1 (poroelastic layer)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Sect. 11.3.3 (printed pp. 251-252), the fluid normal stress of a poroelastic layer and the matrix it feeds.

  • The print: Eq. (11.48) reads

    and Table 11.1 writes in the two columns that carry , and .

  • The problem: two independent misprints in the same equation, plus a subscript slip in the table.

    • The coefficient of the symmetric amplitude is missing: Eq. (11.48) attaches both terms to , which would leave the first and third columns of with no entry at all, contradicting Table 11.1, whose row 6 prints and in exactly those columns. The first term is .
    • The sine carries , the shear wave-number component, inside a sum over the two compressional waves . It must be . Table 11.1 again gives the intended reading: its row 6 has and , and zero in both shear columns, because a shear wave produces no dilatation and therefore no .
    • Table 11.1 prints the running subscript in its first two columns, which belong to the first compressional wave alone: the , and in the same columns make the only consistent reading.
  • Evidence: the two readings above are forced by Table 11.1, which the same page declares to be the tabulation of Eqs. (11.37), (11.38) and (11.46)-(11.48). They are also what the stress-strain relation Eq. (11.41), , gives when the displacement potentials of Eqs. (11.22)-(11.25) are differentiated directly. Verified on PDF page 257 (printed p. 251) and PDF page 258 (printed p. 252) of Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009, which carry Eq. (11.48) and the two Table 11.1 columns as printed.

  • Library behaviour: the of Table 11.1 is implemented with the corrected readings, and test_gamma_matches_the_field_rebuilt_from_the_potentials checks all thirty-six of its entries at three frequencies, three depths and three angles of incidence against the field rebuilt from Eqs. (11.22)-(11.28) without going through the table.

  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Sect. 6.6.3 (thickness of the second sample)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Sect. 6.6.3 (thickness of the second sample)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Sect. 6.6.3, printed p. 129, the two glass-wool samples whose measured and predicted surface impedances are Figures 6.10 and 6.11.
  • The print: the first sentence says the impedances are shown “for l = 10 cm and l = 5.4 cm”; two sentences later the peak of the second sample is placed at “860 Hz for l = 5.6 cm”, and the caption of Figure 6.11 says “l = 5.6 cm”.
  • The problem: the two thicknesses cannot both be right.
  • Evidence: textual, and only textual. Two printed statements carry 5.6 cm, the sentence about the 860 Hz peak and the independent caption of Figure 6.11, against one carrying 5.4 cm; a single slip in the opening sentence is the shorter explanation than the same slip made twice. The numbers do not settle it, and this entry does not claim they do. The book gives no peak-finding rule, and the answer follows the rule chosen:
    • Taking the peak as the maximum of , Eq. (6.107) on the fully specified Table 6.1 glass wool gives 863.5 Hz for 5.6 cm (+0.4 % against the printed 860) and 896.2 Hz for 5.4 cm (+4.2 %), which favours 5.6 cm. But the same rule puts the undisputed 10 cm sample at 480.0 Hz against its printed 470, a +2.1 % bias of the same size as the effect being resolved.
    • Taking the peak as the maximum of , which is the departure the same paragraph describes (“close to each other, except around the peaks which are not predicted by the one-wave model”), the 10 cm sample lands at 469.2 Hz (-0.2 %) and both printed frequencies then come out of the pair (10 cm, 5.4 cm): 861.2 Hz for 5.4 cm (+0.1 %) against 831.0 Hz for 5.6 cm (-3.4 %). That rule favours 5.4 cm.
    • Scaling the 10 cm peak is no help either, and leans the other way from the conclusion: is 10 Hz from the published 860, is 21 Hz from it.
    • The agreement of “860 Hz” with “5.6 cm” is in any case partly circular, since both sit in the same clause: it tests that sentence against itself, not which of the two sentences is the misprint. Verified on PDF page 138 (printed p. 129) of Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009, on which the lone 5.4 cm and the 5.6 cm of the 860 Hz clause sit on the same page, and on PDF page 139 (printed p. 130) of the same edition for the Figure 6.11 caption, the second sentence carrying 5.6 cm.
  • Library behaviour: recorded, with no effect on the implementation. test_impedance_peak_of_the_thin_layer_resolves_the_printed_thickness pins the 5.6 cm peak against the published 860 Hz under the rule and checks that the 5.4 cm reading is the worse of the two under that rule.
  • Status: unreported, and the weakest of the four entries here: the conclusion rests on the two-against-one reading of the printed page, not on a computation.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Sect. 6.5.4 (the frame-borne velocity ratio)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Sect. 6.5.4 (the frame-borne velocity ratio)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Sect. 6.5.4, printed p. 125, the one sentence of the book that quotes computed values of for the Table 6.1 glass wool.
  • The print: “The ratio modulus of the velocities of the frame and the air for the frame-borne wave decreases from 1.0 at 50 Hz to 0.82 at 1500 Hz.”
  • The problem: the two quoted values are the real part of , not its modulus. is complex, and the sentence names the modulus explicitly.
  • Evidence: on the fully specified Table 6.1 material the model gives . Its real part is 0.811, 1.1 % from the printed 0.82; its modulus is 0.939, 14.5 % away. Read as the real part, the sentence is right at both ends and describes a monotone decrease: is 1.002 at 50 Hz and passes through 0.82 at 1467 Hz, 2.2 % from the printed 1500 Hz. Read as the modulus it is right at neither: is 1.002 at 50 Hz but rises to 1.008 by 400 Hz before turning over, and only reaches 0.82 at 2634 Hz, 76 % above the printed frequency. No admissible reading of the printed inputs closes that gap. With the loss factor at 0 or at 0.2, the viscous length halved or doubled, in place of the printed , the resistivity halved or doubled, the tortuosity at 1 or the Poisson coefficient at 0.3, moves only between 0.874 and 1.073. The closest of the eight, 0.874 at zero loss factor, is still 6.6 % from the printed 0.82, and it loses the 495 Hz branch crossing of the same section altogether; the only variant that keeps that crossing (, 495.2 Hz) leaves at 0.937. Reading the sentence as needs no variant at all. Verified on PDF page 134 (printed p. 125) of Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009, which carries the sentence and its 0.82.
  • Library behaviour: biot_waves computes from Eq. (6.71) as printed. The conformance row and test_frame_borne_velocity_ratio_matches_the_two_published_values are written against , and say so.
  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.7 (the figure its caption names)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.7 (the figure its caption names)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Table 11.7, PDF page 280, printed p. 274, the parameter table of the carpet, screen and fibrous layer of Sect. 11.7.2.
  • The print: the caption reads “The parameters used to predict the surface impedance of the material represented in Figure 11.6”.
  • The problem: Figure 11.6 is on printed p. 266 and is the plastic foam under a sheet of glass wool, whose parameters are Table 11.3. The structure Table 11.7 tabulates, a carpet in two layers over an impervious screen over a fibrous layer, is Figure 11.16, printed on the same page as the table.
  • Evidence: the prose beside Figure 11.16 says the material parameters are given in Table 11.7, and the four row names of the table are the four layers Figure 11.16 labels. Verified on PDF page 280 (printed p. 274) and PDF page 272 (printed p. 266) of Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009.
  • Library behaviour: the three porous rows are transcribed as printed and the data file’s about names Figure 11.16 as the structure, with the caption’s own wording quoted.
  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.8 (the thickness of the glass wool)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.8 (the thickness of the glass wool)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Table 11.8, PDF page 281, printed p. 275, the glass wool bonded onto an aluminium plate for the normal-incidence transmission example of Sect. 11.7.3.
  • The print: the table gives the glass wool a thickness of 3,8 mm; the prose of Sect. 11.7.3 on the facing folio says “A layer of the glass wool studied in Section 6.5.4, of thickness 5 cm, is bonded on to a plate of aluminium, of thickness 1 mm”.
  • The problem: the two thicknesses differ by more than an order of magnitude and cannot both describe the layer of Figure 11.18.
  • Evidence: the plate agrees between the two, 1 mm in both, which is what makes the glass wool the disagreeing cell rather than a column read out of order. Verified on PDF page 281 (printed p. 275) for the table and PDF page 280 (printed p. 274) for the sentence, in Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009.
  • Library behaviour: the row carries the printed 3.8 mm, and its note records the sentence. Nothing computes with the thickness: the equivalent fluid of this specimen does not use it.
  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.9 (the thickness of the plate)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 11.9 (the thickness of the plate)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Table 11.9, PDF page 282, printed p. 276, the foam and plate of the diffuse-field transmission example of Sect. 11.7.4.
  • The print: the plate row gives a thickness of 1,6 mm; the prose of Sect. 11.7.4 on the facing folio says “The material is a foam of thickness h = 2 . 54 cm bonded onto a 0.6 mm aluminium plate”.
  • The problem: 1.6 against 0.6 mm for the same plate.
  • Evidence: the foam agrees between the two, the table’s 25.4 mm being the sentence’s 2.54 cm, which places the disagreement in the plate row alone. Verified on PDF page 282 (printed p. 276) for the table and PDF page 281 (printed p. 275) for the sentence, in Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009.
  • Library behaviour: the plate is not a porous material and is not in the catalogue; the foam row’s note records the disagreement so that a reader reproducing the figure knows which plate the curve assumes.
  • Status: unreported.

Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 13.2 (the Young’s modulus of the rockwool)

Section titled “Allard & Atalla 2e (2009), Table 13.2 (the Young’s modulus of the rockwool)”

Textbook, not a standard.

  • Location: Table 13.2, PDF page 341, printed p. 337, the 5.75 cm rockwool with a central perforation of the double-porosity example.
  • The print: the column headed E (Pa) carries 4400 for a frame of 130 kg/m3.
  • The problem: a frame modulus of 4.4 kPa at that density gives a frame wave speed of m/s, so the quarter-wave resonance of a 5.75 cm layer lands near 25 Hz. The text on the next page says the numerical model captures “the skeleton resonance occurring around 1350 Hz”, which the printed modulus cannot produce: 1350 Hz would need about 12.7 MPa, three orders of magnitude above the cell.
  • Evidence: arithmetic on the page’s own two cells against the page’s own sentence. Nothing on the page says what the modulus should be, so this entry reports the inconsistency and does not repair it. Verified on PDF page 341 (printed p. 337) for the table and PDF page 342 (printed p. 338) for the sentence, in Allard & Atalla, Propagation of Sound in Porous Media 2e:2009.
  • Library behaviour: the row carries the printed 4400 Pa and its note records the resonance the text reports. No example of this library computes a skeleton resonance from it.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated